Who votes on a proposal to expand voting rights to a new group
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Who votes on a proposal to expand voting powers to a previously non-voting group within the general membership?
Voting on Proposals to Expand Voting Rights
This is an excellent and nuanced parliamentary question. The answer depends on who currently holds voting rights.
The Core Principle
Those who currently have the right to vote are the ones who vote on any motion — including motions that would expand voting rights to others.
Under Robert's Rules, only members in good standing with the right to vote may vote on any question before the assembly.
Practical Scenarios
If the Change Requires a Bylaw Amendment
- Only current voting members vote on the amendment
- The non-voting group (the proposed beneficiaries) does not vote — they are not yet enfranchised
- Bylaw amendments typically require:
- Previous notice (often required by the bylaws themselves)
- A two-thirds vote, or
- A majority of the entire membership
If It's a Standing Rule or Policy Change
- Again, only current voting members decide
- May require only a majority vote, depending on local rules
Important Caveat
⚠️ Always check your organization's bylaws first. Your bylaws may specify:
- What vote threshold is required
- Whether notice must be given in advance
- Whether certain classes of members have any say in such decisions
Bottom Line
The currently enfranchised members hold the power to decide whether to extend voting rights to others. Those seeking new voting rights have no procedural standing to vote on their own enfranchisement unless the bylaws specifically provide otherwise.