Must an amendment be voted on before the main motion under Robert's Rules
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Does a motion with an amendment on the floor need to be voted on before the main motion?
The Short Answer
No — the amendment is voted on first, before the main motion.
How It Works
When an amendment is moved and seconded while a main motion is on the floor, the assembly deals with the amendment before returning to the main motion. The order is:
- The amendment is debated (debate is limited to the amendment itself)
- The assembly votes on the amendment
- The main motion is then debated (as amended, if the amendment passed)
- The assembly votes on the main motion
Why This Order?
The amendment is a subsidiary motion, which takes precedence over the main motion. The assembly must resolve the amendment before it can act on the underlying motion.
If There Is Also a Secondary Amendment
Things can get one level deeper. If someone moves to amend the amendment, the order becomes:
- Vote on the secondary amendment (the amendment to the amendment)
- Vote on the primary amendment (as modified or not)
- Vote on the main motion (as amended or not)
Note that no third-degree amendments are allowed — you cannot amend an amendment to an amendment.
Practical Takeaway
Think of it as peeling back layers: the assembly always resolves the most recently added layer first, working back to the main motion last.