Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Who decides the agenda when a special meeting request is too broad

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If a request for a special meeting is too broad, or asks too much business to be conducted, how is the call to the meeting then decided?

Deciding the Call for a Special Meeting When the Request Is Too Broad

This is a practical challenge that comes up when members petition for a special meeting but their request is vague, overly broad, or tries to pack in too many items.

Who Decides the Call

The authority to actually issue the call for a special meeting typically rests with the president or the board, as specified in the bylaws. Even when members petition for a special meeting, it is usually the president or board that formally issues the notice — meaning they exercise judgment in shaping the call.

What They May Do

When faced with a broad or overloaded petition, the calling authority has several options:

  1. Narrow the scope — Identify which items are genuinely urgent and include only those in the call. Items that can wait should be held for a regular meeting.

  2. Issue the call for the legitimate items only — If some requested business is proper and some is not, the call can be limited to what is appropriate.

  3. Call multiple separate meetings — If there are distinct topics that each warrant dedicated attention, separate special meetings can be called for each.

  4. Refer the matter to the board — If the president alone received the petition, they may bring it before the board to decide collectively what business justifies a special meeting.

  5. Decline to call the meeting — If the petition is entirely improper or no urgent need exists, the calling authority may decline, though bylaws sometimes give petitioning members a remedy in that case (such as a minimum number of members having the right to compel a meeting).

The Core Principle

The fundamental rule is that only the business specified in the call may be transacted at a special meeting. This means the people issuing the call have both the responsibility and the authority to define what that business will be — and they should define it precisely. A vague or overbroad call creates problems at the meeting itself, since members who stayed home in reliance on the stated purpose are protected from having other business sprung on them.

If There Is a Dispute

If members believe the calling authority improperly narrowed or refused their petition, their recourse depends on the bylaws. Some bylaws allow a sufficient number of petitioning members to call the meeting themselves if officers fail to act. Others may require the matter to come before the full membership at the next regular meeting.

The call should be drafted carefully, stating specific and defined purposes, so that there is no ambiguity about what will and will not be on the agenda.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions