What vote is required to amend draft bylaws before they are adopted
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If someone at a meeting makes a motion to modify draft bylaws that have never been in effect, does approval of that amendment require a simple majority or a supermajority (such as 80%)?
Vote Required to Amend Draft Bylaws
The Short Answer: Majority (50%+1) Most Likely Applies
When a set of bylaws is being initially adopted (i.e., they are still in draft form and have never been in effect), they are treated as an original main motion — not as existing governing documents.
Why the Distinction Matters
| Situation | Vote Required |
|---|---|
| Amending draft bylaws (not yet adopted) | Majority vote (standard amendment rules) |
| Amending existing/adopted bylaws | Whatever the bylaws themselves specify (often 2/3, or 2/3 + previous notice) |
Since the draft bylaws have never been in force, the high amendment thresholds written into the bylaws don't apply yet — you're simply amending a pending main motion.
Robert's Rules — The procedures for adopting a complete set of bylaws treat the document as a main motion subject to amendment by majority vote before final adoption.
The Procedure at the Meeting
- The draft bylaws are presented as a main motion
- Amendments are proposed under standard ** (Amend)** rules
- Each amendment requires a majority vote to adopt
- The final document as a whole is then voted on — typically requiring a majority for initial adoption
Important Caveat
Check your organization's specific rules. If your organization has:
- A parent organization dictating procedures
- Special rules of order already in place
- A specific adoption procedure outlined in a call to the meeting
...those rules could modify this standard.
Bottom line: A supermajority threshold written into the draft bylaws would not apply to motions to amend those bylaws mid-meeting before adoption. Standard majority rules govern amendments to a pending motion.