What to do when the secretary refuses to correct draft minutes before approval
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our secretary refuses to take advice or participate in any board review process to correct the draft minutes before submitting them for approval. What can we do?
Secretary Refusing to Correct Draft Minutes
This is a real governance problem. Here's how to handle it properly under Robert's Rules.
Understanding the Secretary's Role
The secretary does have primary responsibility for preparing draft minutes, but the minutes ultimately belong to the assembly, not the secretary. The board has authority over what gets approved.
Your Options, In Order
Option 1: Amend the Minutes at the Meeting
This is the cleanest solution and requires no secretary cooperation beforehand.
At the approval meeting:
"I move to amend the minutes on page X to read [corrected language]."
- Requires a second
- Debatable
- Passes by majority vote
- The corrected version becomes the official minutes
The secretary must record the approved (corrected) version as the official minutes, regardless of personal preference.
Option 2: Board Review Before Submission
If your board has a minutes review process in your bylaws or standing rules:
- The board can direct the secretary to make specific corrections as a board instruction
- Refusal to follow a board directive is a serious matter (see below)
Option 3: Formal Board Directive
The board can adopt a motion:
"The secretary is directed to revise the draft minutes to reflect [specific corrections] prior to submission for approval."
- Majority vote required
- Creates a formal, recorded obligation to comply
Option 4: Another Member Prepares the Minutes
If the secretary refuses to perform the duty:
Robert's Rules has no specific rule for a secretary who refuses to prepare minutes, but the body the secretary serves controls its own records and can direct another member to prepare a draft for it to correct and approve.
The chair or president can assign preparation of corrected minutes to another member or officer.
If Refusal Continues — Disciplinary Implications
Persistent refusal to perform assigned duties may constitute grounds for:
- Censure (formal reprimand by majority vote)
- Removal from office — if your bylaws authorize it, or by the process in Robert's Rules
- Discipline proceedings
Practical Recommendation
| Situation | Best Action |
|---|---|
| One-time disagreement | Amend at the approval meeting |
| Pattern of non-cooperation | Formal board directive |
| Ongoing refusal | Consider censure or removal |
| Minutes never submitted | Chair assigns another member |
Key Takeaway
The assembly's vote controls what the minutes say — not the secretary's personal preference. A secretary who refuses to record approved corrections is failing their duty under Robert's Rules.