What to do when national bylaws complaint procedure is not being followed
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our national bylaws specify how a complaint is to be handled, and that procedure is not being followed. What can we do?
Bylaws Compliance: Handling a Complaint Procedure Violation
This is a serious matter. When an organization's national bylaws are not being followed, there are several parliamentary remedies available. Here's how to address it:
Immediate Steps
1. Point of Order
- If the violation is occurring in a meeting, raise a Point of Order immediately
- Say: "Point of Order, Mr./Madam Chair"
- State specifically which bylaw provision is being violated
- The chair must rule on it
- Must be raised promptly when the violation occurs (with some exceptions for continuing violations)
2. Appeal the Chair's Ruling
- If the chair rules against you, immediately say: "I appeal the decision of the chair"
- Requires a second
- Is debatable
- Requires a majority to overturn (a tie vote sustains the chair)
If the Violation Already Occurred
3. Raise as a Main Motion
Introduce a motion directing the proper authority to follow the bylaws, such as:
"I move that the complaint be handled in accordance with Article [X], Section [X] of our national bylaws."
Key Principle: Bylaws Are Paramount
Bylaws supersede any other rules, including motions, resolutions, or officer decisions. No vote of the assembly can authorize ignoring bylaws.
Additional Escalation Options
| Situation | Action |
|---|---|
| The board is ignoring bylaws | Bring the matter to a membership meeting |
| Officers are violating bylaws | Disciplinary procedures may apply |
| Ongoing pattern of violations | Consider formal disciplinary action against responsible parties |
| National body is involved | Check whether there is an appeals process in the bylaws themselves |
Important Questions to Consider
- Does your complaint procedure have a specific timeline? If so, document any missed deadlines.
- Who is responsible for handling complaints under the bylaws — an officer, a committee, or the board?
- Is there a national appeals process outlined in the bylaws for exactly this situation?
- Do you have documentation of the deviation from the required procedure?
If you can share more details about what specifically is not being followed, more targeted guidance on the best procedural remedy may be possible.