Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What to do when a member accuses another of lying during a meeting

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


What happens if someone accuses another member of lying during a meeting?

Accusing another member of lying is a serious breach of decorum under Robert's Rules of Order. Here's how it should be handled.

The Problem

Saying that another member "lied" is considered a personal attack and is out of order. Members are expected to direct their remarks to the subject being debated, not to impugn the motives or character of other members.

The Chair's Immediate Response

The chair should intervene at once, calling the member out of order and directing them to confine their remarks to the question before the assembly.

The offending member should withdraw the remark. If they do, the meeting continues.

If the Member Refuses to Withdraw the Remark

The chair has escalating options:

  1. Warn the member formally — the chair calls the member to order by name for making a personal attack on another member.
  2. Refuse to recognize the member for the remainder of that portion of debate.
  3. Direct removal from the meeting if the member continues to be disruptive.
  4. Allow the assembly to act — any member may move that the offending member be required to leave, which requires a majority vote.

The Underlying Concern

If someone genuinely believes false information was presented, the proper course is to:

  • Request that the record reflect the correct information
  • Present evidence or documentation to the contrary
  • Do so respectfully, without accusing the other person of intentional dishonesty

The distinction matters: challenging the accuracy of a statement is acceptable; attacking the character or honesty of a member is not.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions