Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What should a nominating committee do when a nominee fills another position after the slate is published

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A nominating committee was convened and a slate was presented to the general membership. However, after the slate was published, one of the nominees was appointed to fill another board position. What should the nominating committee do to address the resulting vacancy in the slate?

Addressing a Vacancy in the Nominating Committee's Slate

This is a practical and common situation. Here's how it should be handled:

The Nominating Committee's Options

The committee should reconvene and select a new nominee for the now-vacant position on the slate. The committee retains its authority until the election is concluded, and updating the slate falls squarely within its charge.

Once a replacement nominee is identified, the revised slate should be published/distributed to the membership as soon as practicable, following whatever notice requirements your bylaws specify.


At the Election Meeting Itself

Regardless of what the committee does beforehand, the membership retains full rights during the election. Specifically:

  • Any member may be nominated from the floor for any position, even if a nominee already appears on the slate
  • The chair must open the floor for nominations after presenting each office from the slate
  • A nominee on the slate for one position can also be nominated from the floor for a different position

Under Robert's Rules, a nominating committee's report does not close nominations; members may still make further nominations from the floor.


Key Considerations

Issue Guidance
Does the person already appointed remain on the slate? The committee should formally remove them to avoid confusion
Can the appointed member be nominated for the elected position too? Yes — nominations from the floor are always in order
What if bylaws prohibit holding both positions? The chair should note this when that office is reached

Practical Recommendation

  1. Reconvene the committee promptly
  2. Select a replacement nominee (or decide to leave the slot open for floor nominations)
  3. Issue a corrected slate with appropriate notice to the membership
  4. At the meeting, ensure the chair opens the floor for nominations on every office

Check your bylaws and standing rules for any specific requirements about slate publication timelines or notice periods, as those will govern the process locally.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions