What parliamentary remedy addresses offensive remarks that affect a member's dignity
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A speaker makes remarks that offend another member and affect that member's dignity. What parliamentary remedy should the affected member raise?
Parliamentary Remedy for Offensive Remarks
The Appropriate Motion: Question of Privilege
The affected member should raise a question of personal privilege. A question of privilege may relate to the rights and privileges of the assembly as a whole (general privilege) or to those of an individual member (personal privilege). Remarks that injure a member's dignity or reputation fall under personal privilege.
Procedure Step-by-Step
-
The member rises and, if the matter is urgent, interrupts by saying: "Mr./Madam President, I rise to a question of personal privilege."
-
The chair directs the member to state the question.
-
The member states the offense, explaining how the remarks affected their dignity or reputation.
-
The chair rules on whether it is a question of privilege and whether it is urgent enough to interrupt the pending business.
-
The chair or the assembly then acts. The chair may deal with it directly, or the member may make a motion. Possible results include:
- Calling the speaker to order
- Requiring the speaker to withdraw the remarks or apologize
- Referring the matter to a committee
- Other appropriate action
Key Rules
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Can interrupt a speaker | Yes, if the matter is urgent |
| Requires a second | No to raise it; a motion arising from it does |
| Debatable | Only if a motion results |
| Vote required | Majority, if a motion is made |
The Point of Order Alternative
When the offense occurs in debate, a member may also raise a point of order that the speaker is out of order. In debate, a member must not attack or question the motives of another member or use offensive language. Debate is directed at the measure, not at members. The chair should then call the speaker to order.
Relevant Rules
- Questions of privilege: rules on raising a question of privilege, one of the privileged motions
- Decorum in debate: rules governing propriety of language and refraining from personal attacks
- Disciplinary procedures: the rules on breaches of order in meetings, including calling a member to order and naming an offender
Important Note
The chair has independent authority to call a speaker to order for offensive or improper language without waiting for a member to raise the issue. A question of personal privilege is the remedy available to the affected member specifically.