What motion details go in the minutes: maker, seconder, and outcome
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
In our minutes, do we record who made the motion, who seconded it, and the outcome—or just who made the motion and whether it passed?
Recording Motions in Minutes
What Robert's Rules Requires
According to **Robert's Rules, minutes should record:
- ✅ The maker of the motion (who made it) — should be recorded
- ❌ The seconder — should NOT be recorded (unless the assembly orders it)
- ✅ The motion's wording — should be recorded exactly
- ✅ The outcome — should always be recorded, whether it passed or failed
Key Points
On Seconding
Robert's Rules explicitly states that the seconder's name is not recorded in the minutes, as the second is only a procedural formality indicating that at least one other member wants the matter discussed.
On Outcomes
Both adopted AND defeated motions should be recorded. The minutes are a legal record of what the assembly acted upon, not just what passed.
On Votes
If a vote count was taken (e.g., "15 yes, 7 no"), that count should be recorded. If it was a simple voice vote, recording "motion carried" or "motion lost" is sufficient.
Practical Example
*"On a motion by a member that the club purchase a new projector for $500, the motion was carried."
Important Caveat
Your organization's bylaws or standing rules may require additional details (such as recording the seconder). Always check your local rules first.