Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What is the germaneness rule for amendments under Robert's Rules

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Can you explain germaneness as it applies to making amendments to a motion?

Germaneness in Amendments

The Core Rule

When amending a motion, the proposed amendment must be germane to the motion it seeks to modify — meaning it must be directly related to the subject matter of the pending motion. An amendment that introduces an entirely new or unrelated subject is out of order.

Under Robert's Rules, an amendment must be germane to the motion it would amend.


What "Germane" Means in Practice

The amendment must:

  • Relate directly to the same subject as the original motion
  • Modify, narrow, expand, or clarify what the original motion proposes
  • Stay within the scope of the original motion's purpose

The amendment does not need to:

  • Support the original motion
  • Be friendly or acceptable to the maker of the original motion
  • Move things in the same direction as the original motion

An amendment can even be hostile to the original motion — it just must remain on the same subject.


Practical Examples

✅ Germane (In Order)

Main Motion: "That the organization donate $500 to the local food bank."

Amendment: "Strike '$500' and insert '$250'" — ✅ Germane — still about the same donation

Amendment: "Insert 'annually' after 'donate'" — ✅ Germane — modifies the same action


❌ Not Germane (Out of Order)

Main Motion: "That the organization donate $500 to the local food bank."

Amendment: "Add: 'and that we also purchase new office furniture'" — ❌ NOT germane — introduces a completely unrelated subject

Amendment: "Strike the motion and insert language about revising the bylaws" — ❌ NOT germane — changes the entire subject


The Four Ways to Amend

An amendment may propose to:

Method Example
Insert or add words/paragraphs "Insert 'immediately' before 'purchase'"
Strike out words/paragraphs "Strike the word 'annually'"
Strike out and insert "Strike '$500' and insert '$1,000'"
Substitute (replace the entire text) Replace the whole motion with new language

⚠️ Even a substitute must be germane — it must address the same fundamental subject as the original motion.


Levels of Amendment

Robert's Rules allows two levels of amendments:

  1. Primary Amendment — amends the main motion directly
  2. Secondary Amendment — amends the primary amendment

❗ There is no third-degree amendment. You cannot amend an amendment to an amendment.

Both the primary and secondary amendment must each be germane to the motion they are amending.


Raising a Germaneness Objection

If a member believes an amendment is not germane:

  1. Rise and state a Point of Order — "Point of Order: The proposed amendment is not germane to the main motion."
  2. The chair rules on the point immediately
  3. Any member may Appeal the chair's ruling to the assembly (requires a second, debatable, majority vote — a tie sustains the chair's ruling)

Robert's Rules — Point of Order Robert's Rules — Appeal


Key Takeaway

The germaneness rule keeps deliberation focused. It prevents members from hijacking a pending motion to introduce unrelated business. If the subject is truly unrelated, the proper course is to handle it as a separate main motion at the appropriate time.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions