Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What is the correct procedure for handling a substitute motion

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


What is the correct procedure for handling a substitute motion?

Handling a Substitute Motion

A substitute motion is a form of amendment that proposes to replace an entire motion (or a significant portion of it) with different text. It is treated as an amendment of the first degree (primary amendment) using the method of "striking out and inserting." Here is the correct procedure:


1. The Substitute Is Proposed

While a main motion is pending, a member rises and moves to "substitute" new wording for the entire motion. For example:

"I move to substitute the following for the pending motion: [new text]..."

  • This requires a second
  • It is debatable
  • It requires a majority vote to adopt

2. Both Motions Are Open to Amendment

This is the critical procedural point that is often misunderstood. Once a substitute is pending, both the original motion AND the substitute are open to amendment before the vote on the substitute is taken.

  • Members may offer secondary amendments to either the original text or the substitute text
  • This gives the assembly the opportunity to perfect both versions before choosing between them

3. Vote on the Substitute (Primary Amendment)

Once debate and amendment of both versions is complete, the assembly votes on the substitute itself:

  • If the substitute PASSES → The substitute replaces the original motion, and the assembly then votes on the substituted motion as the main question
  • If the substitute FAILS → The original motion (as amended, if applicable) remains before the assembly

4. Vote on the Main Motion

After the substitute question is resolved, the assembly proceeds to vote on the main motion in whatever form it now exists.


Key Points to Remember

Aspect Rule
Type of motion Primary amendment (amend by substitution)
Requires second Yes
Debatable Yes
Vote required Majority
Amendable Yes — both versions may be amended
Effect if adopted Replaces entire original motion

Important Caution

A substitute motion is not a separate main motion — it is an amendment. The chair should not treat it as a new main motion or allow it to simply replace the pending motion without a vote. The assembly has the right to choose between the two versions (as perfected by amendment).


Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions