What is a substitute motion under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What's a substitute motion?
Substitute Motion
A substitute motion is a form of amendment that proposes to replace an entire motion (or an entire section/paragraph) with new text. It is technically an amendment of the third type — "to substitute" — and is treated as a primary amendment.
How It Works
When a member believes the pending motion should be replaced wholesale rather than modified piece by piece, they move to substitute the entire motion with different language. For example:
"I move to substitute the following motion for the one pending: [new text]"
Key Procedural Rules
| Feature | Rule |
|---|---|
| Requires a second? | Yes |
| Debatable? | Yes |
| Vote required? | Majority |
| Amendable? | Yes — both the original AND the substitute can be amended before the vote on substitution |
Important Points
- Both versions stay open for amendment before the assembly votes on whether to substitute. This allows the body to perfect each version before choosing between them.
- If the substitute is adopted, it becomes the pending motion (and is then open to further amendment).
- If the substitute is rejected, the original motion continues as before.
- A substitute is not a separate main motion — it is an amendment and follows amendment rules.
Practical Use
Substitutes are useful when a member wants to offer a complete alternative approach rather than making multiple individual amendments. It gives the assembly a clean choice between two fully-formed versions of a proposal.