What is a motion of censure under Robert's Rules
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can you describe a motion of censure?
Motion of Censure
What It Is
A motion of censure is a formal expression of disapproval, condemnation, or reprimand directed at an officer, member, or the assembly's own previous action. It is one of the disciplinary tools available to a deliberative body short of removal from office or expulsion.
Key Characteristics
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Type | Main motion |
| Vote Required | Majority vote |
| Debatable | Yes |
| Amendable | Yes |
| Effect | Formal rebuke — no other direct penalty |
What It Does (and Doesn't Do)
- ✅ Places a formal, public reprimand on record
- ✅ Expresses the assembly's collective disapproval
- ✅ Can be directed at a member, officer, or committee
- ❌ Does not remove the person from office
- ❌ Does not suspend or expel the member
- ❌ Carries no automatic penalty beyond the rebuke itself
How It Is Introduced
It is introduced as a standard main motion:
"I move that the assembly censure [the officer/member] for [specific conduct]."
It then follows normal main motion procedure:
- Second required
- Open to debate
- May be amended
- Decided by majority vote
Important Procedural Notes
- The accused member has the right to be heard in their own defense before the vote
- Censure is typically used for less serious infractions; more serious misconduct may warrant formal disciplinary procedures including a trial
- The motion should clearly state the specific conduct being censured to be meaningful and fair
Distinction from Removal
| Action | Vote Required | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Censure | Majority | Formal rebuke only |
| Remove from Office | Varies (often 2/3) | Loss of position |
| Expulsion | 2/3 | Loss of membership |
Practical Consideration
Because censure carries no tangible penalty, its power is primarily moral and reputational. Its effectiveness depends largely on the culture and norms of the organization. In some bodies it carries significant weight; in others it may have little practical effect.
Robert's Rules Reference: Robert's Rules addresses disciplinary procedures; censure is discussed as a disciplinary measure short of formal trial proceedings.