What happens when the board violates bylaw nomination timelines
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our bylaws set a specific timeline for submitting nominees for board positions. What happens if the board violates this requirement?
Bylaw Violations in the Nomination Process
The short answer is: bylaw violations are serious matters with real procedural consequences, but the remedy depends on when the violation is discovered and what your bylaws specify.
General Principles
Bylaws are the supreme governing document of an organization (subject only to applicable law and any superior governing documents). A board that fails to follow bylaw requirements is acting outside its authority.
Under Robert's Rules, the bylaws contain the organization's own basic rules and take precedence over its rules of order, standing rules, and parliamentary authority; only applicable law and a corporate charter rank above them.
Potential Consequences & Remedies
1. Point of Order
Any member may raise a Point of Order to formally object that the nomination process violated the bylaws. This should be raised as soon as the violation becomes apparent.
⚠️ Timing matters: Points of order regarding violations of bylaws must generally be raised promptly or the right to object may be waived — except for continuing violations affecting fundamental rights, which may be raised at any time.
2. The Nominations or Election May Be Challengeable
If the bylaw timeline was not followed:
- The resulting nominations or election could potentially be ruled invalid
- The chair or assembly can rule that improperly submitted nominations are out of order
- Members could appeal the chair's ruling if they disagree
3. The Assembly Has Authority to Act
The full membership assembly (not just the board) has ultimate authority to:
- Declare the nominations void and restart the process
- Refer the matter to a committee for investigation
- Take disciplinary action if warranted
4. Practical Steps to Take
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| Document | Record the specific bylaw language and the exact violation |
| Act promptly | Raise concerns as early as possible |
| Raise a Point of Order | At the next meeting or relevant proceedings |
| Demand the process restart | If nominations were improperly handled |
| Consult an attorney | If the election has already occurred and members' rights are at stake |
Important Caveats
- Your specific bylaw language matters enormously — if the bylaw says nominations "shall" be submitted by a date, that's mandatory; "should" may be treated as directory only
- If the election has already been completed, reversing it is more complex and may require a motion to rescind or legal action depending on circumstances
- Some organizations have specific remedies written into their bylaws for violations — check yours
Bottom Line
A board that violates its own bylaws has acted improperly, and the membership has both the right and the authority to demand compliance. The most important thing is to raise the issue promptly and formally through proper parliamentary channels.