What happens when an executive committee vote ends in a tie
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What happens if an executive committee vote ends in a tie?
Tie Votes in an Executive Committee
The General Rule
A tie vote means the motion FAILS. A majority is required to adopt a motion, and a tie does not constitute a majority. The motion is therefore defeated.
Under Robert's Rules, a tie vote is not a majority, so a motion that requires a majority vote is lost on a tie.
The Chair's Vote in Committee
In an executive committee (or any small board/committee), the rules are slightly different from a full assembly:
- The chair votes along with all other members on all questions (small boards and committees rule)
- Unlike the chair of a full assembly, the committee chair is not limited to only breaking ties; they vote as a regular member
- Therefore, the chair's vote is already included in the tally
This means if the vote is tied after the chair has voted, the motion simply fails — there is no "tiebreaker" available.
Practical Implications
| Situation | Result |
|---|---|
| Tie vote on a main motion | Motion fails |
| Tie vote on an amendment | Amendment fails |
| Tie vote on an appeal | Tie sustains the chair's ruling (special rule) |
Options After a Failed Tie Vote
The committee may:
- Move to Reconsider the vote (if a member who voted with the majority wishes to do so)
- Bring the matter back at a future meeting as a new motion
- Refer the matter to the full board for decision