Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What happens when a vote results in a tie under Robert's Rules

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


What is the outcome of a tied vote?

When a vote results in a tie, the motion fails.

This is because a motion requires a majority of votes cast to be adopted. In a tie, the affirmative votes do not constitute a majority — they represent exactly half of the votes cast, which is not sufficient for the motion to prevail.

Example: If the vote is 10 in favor and 10 opposed, the motion fails.

The Chair's Role in a Tie

In most organizations, the chair does not vote routinely, but may vote when the outcome hangs in the balance:

  • To break a tie — The chair may vote in the affirmative, which would adopt the motion.
  • To create a tie — If the vote would otherwise pass, the chair may vote in the negative, creating a tie and defeating the motion.

This practice preserves the chair's impartiality during debate while still protecting the chair's rights as a member.

Exception: In small boards, the chair typically votes along with all other members on every question, just as any other member would.

Appeals

There is one notable special case: when a member appeals the chair's ruling and the vote on the appeal results in a tie, the tie sustains the chair's decision by convention, rather than overturning it.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions