What happens when a vote is tied or cannot be decided under Robert's Rules
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What happens when an item of business comes up for a vote and cannot be decided, or the vote ends in a tie?
Handling Undecided Votes and Ties
Robert's Rules addresses several scenarios where a vote cannot be conclusively decided. Here's a breakdown:
Tie Votes
A tie vote means the motion FAILS. Under Robert's Rules, a motion requires a majority (more than half of votes cast) to pass. If the vote is tied, the motion has not achieved a majority and is therefore defeated.
Robert's Rules — A majority vote means more than half of the votes cast. A tie is not a majority.
The Chair's Role in a Tie
- In most assemblies, the chair may cast a deciding vote to break (or create) a tie
- The chair is never required to vote, but may choose to do so
- This is one of the few times the presiding officer participates in voting
When a Vote Cannot Be Decided
If business cannot be resolved, the assembly has several options:
| Motion | Effect | Vote Required |
|---|---|---|
| Postpone Definitely | Delay to a specific future time/meeting | Majority |
| Refer to Committee | Send for study and recommendation | Majority |
| Postpone Indefinitely | Effectively kills the motion | Majority |
| Lay on the Table | Set aside temporarily (to return later) | Majority |
Practical Recommendations
- If more information is needed → Refer to a committee
- If timing is wrong → Postpone to a specific date
- If the motion should simply go away → Postpone Indefinitely
- If something urgent has arisen → Lay on the Table
Important Note on "No Action"
If no motion is made regarding the tied or stalled item, the default result is that the motion fails and business simply moves on. The matter could be brought up again at a future meeting as a new main motion.