Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What happens when a motion to refer omits committee size or deadline

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A motion to refer a matter to a committee was voted on and approved by the membership, but the original motion did not specify the size of the committee. How is this resolved?

Resolving an Unspecified Committee Size

This is a common situation and Robert's Rules provides clear guidance on how to handle it.

Who Determines Committee Composition

When a motion to refer to committee is adopted without specifying the committee's size or membership, the authority to determine those details falls to the chair — unless the assembly has another rule governing this.

**Robert's Rules provides that a motion to commit/refer may include details such as size, membership, and instructions, but if these are omitted, the chair generally has the authority to appoint the committee.


Practical Resolution Steps

  1. The chair appoints the committee, determining its size at the time of appointment, based on what is reasonable for the task

  2. The chair should use good judgment — a small, focused committee (typically 3–5 members) is generally most effective for most tasks

  3. If members feel the chair's appointments are inappropriate, they may raise a point of order or move to reconsider the referral motion and amend it to specify size


Best Practice Going Forward

When making a motion to refer, best practice is to specify:

  • Size of the committee
  • How members are selected (appointed by chair, elected by assembly, etc.)
  • Any specific instructions
  • Reporting deadline (if applicable)

If the Assembly Wants to Retain Control

If the membership wants to determine committee size themselves rather than leaving it to the chair, they can:

  • Move to reconsider the referral vote (must be done timely, typically the same session)
  • Amend the motion to include size specifications before final adoption
Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions