What happens when a motion to refer omits committee size or deadline
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a motion to refer a matter to a committee was voted on, but the motion did not specify the size of the committee or a reporting deadline, how is this resolved?
Resolving an Incomplete Motion to Refer
This is a common situation, and Robert's Rules provides clear guidance on how to handle it.
Short Answer
When a motion to refer fails to specify committee size or reporting deadline, the assembly retains control and these details can be addressed through subsequent action.
How Committee Size is Determined
If the motion did not specify:
- The chair appoints the committee unless the bylaws or the motion specify otherwise
- The assembly can still instruct the chair on the number of members through a subsequent motion
- If the committee was established but size left open, a motion to fix the size can be made as new business
How the Reporting Deadline is Handled
Without a specified deadline:
- The committee reports when it is ready, or
- When the assembly calls for the report through a motion to instruct the committee to report by a certain date
- The assembly can pass a subsequent motion instructing the committee to report at a specific meeting or by a specific date (majority vote required)
Practical Remedies
| Problem | Solution |
|---|---|
| Size not specified | Chair appoints; assembly can direct by motion |
| No deadline given | Assembly passes a motion setting a deadline |
| Both unspecified | A single motion can address both simultaneously |
Key Takeaway
The assembly always retains authority over its committees and can provide additional instructions at any time via a majority vote motion to instruct the committee.
If the committee has already begun work, a motion to instruct is still proper and takes effect immediately upon adoption.