Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What happens when a motion receives no second under Robert's Rules

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If someone proposes a motion but no one seconds it, how should the chair rule?

Motion Without a Second

When a motion fails to receive a second, the chair should handle it as follows:

Proper Procedure

After the chair states "Is there a second?" and no second is forthcoming, the chair simply announces:

"The motion is not before the assembly, as it has not received a second."

The chair then moves on to the next item of business. The motion is not debated, not voted on, and not recorded in the minutes (since it never officially came before the assembly).


Important Details
  • No ruling is required — the chair simply declares the motion has failed to come before the body. It is not a ruling that can be appealed.
  • The minutes should NOT record the failed motion, since it never became pending business.
  • The member may try again — nothing prevents the member from renewing the motion later, or asking another member to second it before making it formally.

Key Exceptions — When No Second Is Needed

Some motions do not require a second:

  • Point of Order
  • Point of Information / Parliamentary Inquiry
  • Division of the Assembly
  • Motions made by a committee (since the committee itself implies multiple members)

Practical Note

In small boards (fewer than about 12 members), seconds are often dispensed with entirely, as the chair can simply ask "Is there any discussion?" to gauge interest.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions