Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What happens when a motion has no defined outcome or consequences

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


What happens if a member proposes a motion but the outcome is not clearly defined and the mover cannot articulate concrete consequences?

Motions with Undefined Outcomes or Consequences

Here's how Robert's Rules addresses this situation:


The Core Requirement: A Motion Must Be Clear

Under Robert's Rules, a motion must be clear enough for members to understand what they are voting on. The chair has both the right and the duty to ensure this.


What the Chair Can Do

1. Decline to State the Motion

If a motion is too vague, ambiguous, or undefined, the chair may rule it out of order and decline to put it before the assembly until it is properly formulated.

2. Request Clarification

The chair may ask the mover to clarify or restate the motion before recognizing it formally.

3. Allow Amendment from the Floor

The motion can be allowed on the floor and then amended by members to add specificity and concrete language.


What Members Can Do

Option Effect
Move to Amend Add specific language defining the outcome
Postpone Definitely Delay until the mover can develop clearer language
Refer to Committee Send to committee to draft a workable resolution
Vote it Down Simply defeat it due to lack of substance

Important Distinction: Resolutions

A resolution typically follows the format:

"WHEREAS [reasons]... BE IT RESOLVED THAT [specific action]..."

If the "BE IT RESOLVED" clause lacks concrete, actionable language, the motion arguably accomplishes nothing even if passed—which is itself grounds for the chair to question its suitability.


Key Principle

A motion that cannot be carried out or has no definable effect may be ruled out of order as an impossible or meaningless motion.


Practical Advice

If you find yourself in this situation, the best procedural path is usually:

  1. Move to refer to a committee with instructions to return a fully developed motion
  2. Or move to postpone definitely to give the mover time to clarify
Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions