What happens when a bylaw amendment is introduced under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A bylaw amendment was introduced as new business. What do we do now, and when does the vote take place?
Bylaw Amendment Procedure Under Robert's Rules
Bylaw amendments follow a special process distinct from ordinary main motions. Here's what happens:
Immediate Steps When Introduced
- The motion is made and seconded
- The chair states the motion — bringing it officially before the assembly
- Debate opens — members may discuss the proposed amendment
⚠️ Critical Question: When Does the Vote Occur?
This depends on your bylaws themselves, which typically specify notice and voting requirements. Look for language covering:
1. Previous Notice Requirement
Most bylaws require that amendments be announced in advance (e.g., in the meeting call or at a prior meeting). Robert's Rules strongly recommends this —
- If proper notice was given → The assembly may debate and vote at this meeting
- If NO notice was given → The amendment generally cannot be voted on today
2. Vote Threshold
Bylaw amendments typically require:
- A two-thirds (2/3) vote, OR
- A majority of the entire membership, OR
- Both notice AND a supermajority
(Check your specific bylaws)
If Notice Was NOT Given
The proper course is usually to:
- Refer it to a committee, OR
- Postpone it to a future meeting with proper notice given in the interim
What to Check in Your Bylaws
| Provision | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Notice requirement | How far in advance? Written? To whom? |
| Vote required | 2/3? Majority of membership? |
| Who may propose | Any member? Board only? |
Bottom line: Before proceeding to a vote, verify that your bylaws' notice requirements have been satisfied. If they haven't, the vote should be postponed until proper notice is given.