Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What does the chair do when a pre-submitted motion is out of order

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


When a motion submitted in advance is out of order, what does the chair do?

Ruling a Pre-Submitted Motion Out of Order

When a motion submitted in advance is determined to be out of order, the chair handles it the same way as any other out-of-order motion:


The Chair's Procedure
  1. When the motion is called up, the chair rules on it immediately before allowing any debate or secondary motions to be entertained.

  2. The chair states the ruling clearly:

    "The chair rules this motion out of order because [reason]."

  3. The chair briefly explains the reason, which may include:

    • The motion conflicts with the bylaws or governing documents
    • The motion conflicts with a previously adopted motion still in effect
    • The motion is outside the society's object or jurisdiction
    • The motion violates applicable law
    • Proper notice requirements were not met

Important Notes
  • The member's right to appeal — Any member may Appeal the chair's ruling. The appeal requires a second, is debatable, and is decided by majority vote (a tie vote sustains the chair's ruling).

  • Advance submission does not validate a motion — The fact that it was submitted in advance does not make an otherwise improper motion in order. The chair retains full authority to rule on its propriety when it comes before the assembly.

  • The motion is not simply skipped silently — The chair should openly rule it out of order rather than ignoring it, so the member has the opportunity to appeal if they disagree.


Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions