What does it mean to vote to sustain on an appeal under Robert's Rules
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What does it mean when a board member votes to "sustain" in a motion?
Voting to "Sustain" in Parliamentary Procedure
The word "sustain" appears specifically in the context of an Appeal — not in regular motions. Here's what it means:
What Is an Appeal?
When the chair makes a ruling (such as on a Point of Order), any member can Appeal the decision of the chair to the full assembly. This asks the group: "Do you agree with the chair's ruling?"
The question put to the assembly is typically:
"Shall the decision of the chair be sustained?"
How to Interpret the Vote
| Vote | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Yes / Aye | You agree with the chair's ruling — you are sustaining it |
| No / Nay | You disagree with the chair's ruling — you want to overturn it |
Key Rules for Appeals
- Requires a second
- Is debatable (with some exceptions)
- Requires a majority vote to overturn the chair
- A tie vote sustains the chair's decision (the chair wins ties)
- The chair may vote on an appeal
In Summary
When a member votes to sustain, they are siding with the chair's ruling and want it to stand as decided.