What decision-making tools does a committee have beyond yes/no motions
Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How can I make decisions about things my committee has been tasked with that aren't simple yes/no motions?
Decision-Making Tools Beyond Simple Yes/No Motions
Robert's Rules provides several procedural tools that help committees work through complex decisions. Here are the most useful approaches:
1. Motions with Instructions
When referring something to a subcommittee or taking action, you can include specific directions:
"I move that we adopt Option B for the budget, with the instruction that the treasurer prepare a detailed implementation timeline."
This builds nuance directly into the motion.
2. **Filling Blanks
Perfect for decisions involving numbers, names, dates, or amounts where you want to consider multiple options simultaneously.
How it works:
- A member proposes a motion with a "blank" — "I move we allocate $___ to the project"
- Members suggest amounts to fill the blank
- All suggestions are voted on in sequence (largest amounts first for money, earliest dates first for dates)
- The first one to pass fills the blank
- Then the completed motion is voted on
This avoids the problem of competing amendments crowding each other out.
3. Series of Related Motions
Break a complex decision into sequential votes:
- First motion: Adopt the general framework
- Second motion: Approve the specific timeline
- Third motion: Authorize the chair to act
4. **Refer to a Subcommittee
If a decision needs more research before the full committee can act wisely:
"I move we refer this matter to a subcommittee of three, to report back at our next meeting with a recommendation."
5. **Postpone to a Fixed Time
If the committee needs more information before deciding:
"I move we postpone this question to our next meeting, pending receipt of the cost analysis."
6. Consider Seriatim
For long documents or multi-part proposals, the committee can go through them section by section, amending each part before a final vote on the whole document.
Key Tip for Committees
Committees operate under more relaxed rules than full assemblies. Specifically:
- Members can speak multiple times on the same question
- The chair can participate in debate and make motions
- Informal discussion is encouraged before motions are made
- Votes can often be taken by consensus (unanimous consent) on routine matters