Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


What decision-making tools does a committee have beyond yes/no motions

Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


How can I make decisions about things my committee has been tasked with that aren't simple yes/no motions?

Decision-Making Tools Beyond Simple Yes/No Motions

Robert's Rules provides several procedural tools that help committees work through complex decisions. Here are the most useful approaches:


1. Motions with Instructions

When referring something to a subcommittee or taking action, you can include specific directions:

"I move that we adopt Option B for the budget, with the instruction that the treasurer prepare a detailed implementation timeline."

This builds nuance directly into the motion.


2. **Filling Blanks

Perfect for decisions involving numbers, names, dates, or amounts where you want to consider multiple options simultaneously.

How it works:

  1. A member proposes a motion with a "blank" — "I move we allocate $___ to the project"
  2. Members suggest amounts to fill the blank
  3. All suggestions are voted on in sequence (largest amounts first for money, earliest dates first for dates)
  4. The first one to pass fills the blank
  5. Then the completed motion is voted on

This avoids the problem of competing amendments crowding each other out.


3. Series of Related Motions

Break a complex decision into sequential votes:

  • First motion: Adopt the general framework
  • Second motion: Approve the specific timeline
  • Third motion: Authorize the chair to act

4. **Refer to a Subcommittee

If a decision needs more research before the full committee can act wisely:

"I move we refer this matter to a subcommittee of three, to report back at our next meeting with a recommendation."


5. **Postpone to a Fixed Time

If the committee needs more information before deciding:

"I move we postpone this question to our next meeting, pending receipt of the cost analysis."


6. Consider Seriatim

For long documents or multi-part proposals, the committee can go through them section by section, amending each part before a final vote on the whole document.


Key Tip for Committees

Committees operate under more relaxed rules than full assemblies. Specifically:

  • Members can speak multiple times on the same question
  • The chair can participate in debate and make motions
  • Informal discussion is encouraged before motions are made
  • Votes can often be taken by consensus (unanimous consent) on routine matters
Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions