What can the chair do when the recording secretary defies their authority
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What can the chair or presiding officer do when the recording secretary is defying their authority and refusing to follow directions during a meeting?
What Can the Chair Do When the Recording Secretary Defies Their Authority?
This is a serious situation involving a fundamental conflict of authority. Here's how Robert's Rules addresses it:
The Basic Framework
The presiding officer chairs the meeting and controls the proceedings. The recording secretary's role is to record the minutes — not to make rulings, control debate, or override the chair.
However, the secretary does have certain independent duties that cannot simply be overridden.
Common Scenarios and How to Handle Them
1. Secretary Refuses to Record What the Chair Directs
- The chair may direct the secretary on the form of minutes entries
- The assembly itself has final authority over what the minutes contain
- Any member may move to amend the minutes at approval time — Minutes are the record of the assembly, not the secretary's personal account
2. Secretary Acts as a Second Presiding Officer
- This is clearly out of order
- The chair should rule the secretary out of order firmly and immediately
- If the secretary persists, the chair may direct them to be seated
3. Secretary Refuses to Perform Duties
- The chair may ask the assembly to appoint a secretary pro tempore to perform the duties for that meeting — The assembly has authority to address this
Escalation Options for the Assembly
If the problem is serious and ongoing:
| Action | Details |
|---|---|
| Censure | Formal expression of disapproval — requires majority vote |
| Removal from office | Must follow bylaws provisions; if none, Robert's Rules applies |
| Suspend from duties | Pending disciplinary proceedings if warranted |
Key Point on Removal
Robert's Rules ** states that an officer may be removed from office by a two-thirds vote of the assembly (with notice), or by a majority vote of the entire membership — provided the bylaws don't specify otherwise.
Always check your bylaws first — they may have specific discipline or removal procedures that must be followed.
Recommended Immediate Steps
- Chair firmly asserts authority in the meeting
- Rule disruptive conduct out of order
- If unresolvable in the meeting, appoint a secretary pro tempore
- After the meeting, consult bylaws on discipline and removal procedures