What are the limits on the content of a motion or resolution
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a member wants to make a motion to approve a resolution, what are the limits on what the resolution can be about?
Limits on the Content of a Main Motion (Resolution)
General Rule: The Germaneness/Scope Principle
Under Robert's Rules, the primary limits on what a main motion or resolution can address fall into several categories:
1. It Must Be Within the Scope of the Assembly's Authority
The motion cannot direct the body to do something it lacks the power to do. A faculty senate, for example, cannot pass a resolution binding a board of trustees if it has no authority over them.
2. It Cannot Conflict with Higher Governing Documents
The resolution must not violate, in order of precedence:
- Applicable law
- The organization's charter or articles
- The constitution/bylaws
- Any standing rules of the body
3. It Must Relate to the Organization's Purpose
The subject matter should be within the proper purview of the assembly. If the bylaws define the scope of the body's authority (e.g., curriculum, academic standards for a faculty senate), a resolution far outside that scope could be ruled out of order.
4. It Cannot Conflict with Motions Already Adopted
A main motion that contradicts a previously adopted motion is out of order unless it is brought forward as a motion to Rescind or Amend Something Previously Adopted.
5. It Must Not Be Frivolous or Against Fundamental Principles of Parliamentary Law
A motion that is inherently impossible to carry out or that violates basic ethical or procedural principles may be ruled out of order by the chair.
Important Practical Note: Content vs. Wisdom
The chair rules on whether a motion is in order — not whether it is a good idea. The assembly itself decides the wisdom of the resolution through debate and vote.
The Chair's Role
If a proposed resolution is out of order, the presiding officer should rule it out of order before it is debated. Any member may also raise a Point of Order if they believe the motion exceeds the body's authority.
Bottom line: As long as the resolution is within the body's authority, doesn't conflict with governing documents, and isn't a repeat of a recently decided question, it is generally in order. The assembly then debates and votes on its merits.