What are negative motions and why does Robert's Rules discourage them
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What are negative motions?
Negative Motions in Parliamentary Procedure
What They Are
A negative motion is a main motion that is worded in the negative — meaning it proposes that the assembly not do something, or that something be opposed or rejected.
Examples:
- "I move that we do not increase dues."
- "I move that we oppose the proposed legislation."
- "I move that the organization take no action on this matter."
Why They Are Problematic
Robert's Rules discourages negative motions because they create confusing voting situations:
A "yes" vote means you support doing nothing A "no" vote means you want something done
This reversal of the natural meaning of "yes" and "no" can confuse members and lead to misinterpreted results.
What Robert's Rules Recommends Instead
The chair should restate the motion in the affirmative when possible, or members should be encouraged to rephrase it. For example:
| Instead of... | Use... |
|---|---|
| "I move we do NOT increase dues." | "I move that dues remain at their current level." |
| "I move we take no action." | Allow the main motion to simply fail on a vote |
The Better Alternative
Often the best solution is simply to vote down the affirmative motion rather than adopt a negative one. Defeating "I move we increase dues" accomplishes the same result as adopting "I move we not increase dues" — without the confusion.
Key Takeaway
Negative motions are not prohibited, but they are poor practice and should be avoided or rephrased whenever possible.