What amendments to a bylaw amendment can be proposed from the floor
Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
When an amendment to the constitution or bylaws is under discussion, what kinds of amendments to it can be proposed from the floor?
Amendments to Bylaws/Constitution Amendments
The Short Answer
When a proposed amendment to the bylaws or constitution is pending before the assembly, primary and secondary amendments may be offered from the floor — but with an important limitation regarding scope.
The Rules That Apply
Primary and Secondary Amendments Are Permitted
The pending bylaw amendment is itself treated as a main motion, so it is subject to the normal amendment process:
- A primary amendment (amendment of the first degree) may be proposed to modify the pending bylaw amendment
- A secondary amendment (amendment of the second degree) may be proposed to modify the primary amendment
- No third-degree amendments are permitted — you cannot amend an amendment to an amendment
The Critical Limitation: Scope of Notice
This is the most important constraint. Under Robert's Rules., **, floor amendments to a bylaw amendment:
Must be within the scope of the notice that was given to members.
This means a floor amendment may make the change smaller or more narrow, but it may not go beyond what was noticed. Specifically, a floor amendment cannot:
- Introduce a change that is more radical or extensive than what was included in the original notice
- Amend portions of the bylaws that were not referenced in the notice
Practical Example
If notice was given that the proposed amendment would increase the membership dues from $50 to $100, a floor amendment could:
- ✅ Propose to increase dues to $75 instead (a lesser change, within scope)
- ❌ Propose to increase dues to $150 (exceeds the scope of notice)
- ❌ Propose to also change the meeting frequency (outside the scope of notice entirely)
Why This Rule Exists
The notice requirement protects members by ensuring they can make an informed decision about whether to attend a meeting. Allowing floor amendments that exceed the noticed change would defeat that protection.
Key Takeaway
Floor amendments are permitted, but they are bounded by the principle that members are entitled to know in advance the outer limits of what might be changed. When in doubt, the chair should rule any amendment out of order that would result in a change more extensive than what was noticed.