Should you record the names of motion makers and seconders in minutes
Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Do you need to record the name of the person presenting a motion and the person who seconds the motion?
Recording Motions in Minutes
Short answer: The maker of the motion should be recorded, but the seconder generally should NOT be recorded.
The Maker of the Motion
Robert's Rules states that minutes should record the name of the maker of each main motion (and other motions that come to a vote). This is the standard practice.
Robert's Rules
The Seconder
Robert's Rules explicitly states that the seconder's name is NOT recorded in the minutes, unless the assembly orders it by a specific vote.
The rationale is straightforward: a second merely indicates that at least one other member wants the matter discussed — it carries no particular significance beyond that threshold requirement.
Practical Summary
| Element | Record in Minutes? |
|---|---|
| Name of motion maker | ✅ Yes |
| Name of seconder | ❌ No (unless ordered by the assembly) |
| The motion's exact wording | ✅ Yes |
| The vote outcome | ✅ Yes |
Important Caveat
Your organization's bylaws or standing rules may impose different requirements. Always check local rules first, as they supersede Robert's Rules on this point if they specifically address it.