Should a motion withdrawn before the chair states the question be recorded in minutes
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Before a motion is stated by the chair, the maker requested to postpone its introduction to a future meeting. How is that recorded in the minutes?
Recording a Withdrawn Motion in the Minutes
When a maker withdraws a motion before the chair has stated the question, the motion is treated as though it was never made — and that principle governs how it appears in the minutes.
The Short Answer: It Is Not Recorded
Because the motion was never formally before the assembly (the chair had not yet stated the question), there is nothing to record. The minutes should reflect only official business of the assembly, and a motion that was withdrawn before being stated has no official standing.
Why This Is the Case
- The minutes record what the assembly did, not what individual members proposed informally
- A motion withdrawn before the chair states the question leaves no parliamentary footprint
- Recording it could create confusion about whether the assembly took any action on the matter
A Practical Note
If the member intends to bring the matter to a future meeting, they are free to do so simply by making the motion at that later meeting. No formal "carry-over" exists in the record, and no reference to the earlier attempt is needed or appropriate.
If the Withdrawal Happened After the Chair Stated the Question
That situation is different — the assembly would have granted permission to withdraw, and that action would appear in the minutes, since the assembly itself took action.