Procedure and presiding officer script for a general revision of bylaws
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What are the details of the procedure for considering a general revision of the bylaws? What is the script for the presiding officer?
Procedure for Considering a General Revision
A general revision is a complete rewrite or thorough reorganization of an entire document (bylaws, constitution, etc.), as distinguished from making several individual amendments. Robert's Rules treats this as a special procedure.
Background: How a General Revision Comes Before the Assembly
A general revision is typically proposed by:
- A revision committee appointed to draft a complete new document, OR
- A special committee instructed to prepare a revision
The committee presents an entirely new draft document, which is then considered article by article (or section by section).
Key Principle: The Old Document Remains in Force
The existing document remains in effect until the new revision is fully adopted as a whole at the end of the process. The assembly is not amending the old document — it is considering a new proposed document.
Step-by-Step Procedure
Step 1 — Receiving the Revision
The committee chair (or a designated member) presents the proposed revision to the assembly.
"The committee on revision of the bylaws presents the following proposed revision..."
The report is received. A motion to substitute the new document for the old one is made (or the chair treats the committee's report as the basis for consideration).
Step 2 — Opening the Document for Amendment
The chair opens the proposed revision for amendment section by section (or article by article). Members may amend each section as it is called.
Critically: At this stage, members are amending the proposed new document, NOT the existing bylaws.
Step 3 — Considering Each Section
The chair calls each section in order:
"The first section [read aloud or summarized]. Are there any amendments to Section 1?"
- Members may move to amend any section
- Amendments follow standard amendment procedure
- When no further amendments are offered to a section, the chair moves to the next
"There are no further amendments to Section 1. We now move to Section 2..."
Step 4 — Open the Floor After All Sections
After all sections have been considered:
"All sections of the proposed revision have been considered. The document is now open for any amendments to any section."
This gives members a final opportunity to make any additional changes.
Step 5 — Voting on Adoption of the Whole
After all amendments have been disposed of, the chair puts the final vote on adopting the entire revision:
"The question is on the adoption of the proposed revision to the bylaws as amended. Those in favor of adopting the revision as a whole, say aye... Those opposed, say no... The ayes have it and the proposed revision is adopted. The new bylaws are now in effect."
Vote required: Whatever threshold is required by the bylaws for amendment (typically two-thirds plus previous notice, or a majority of the entire membership) —
Presiding Officer Script
Below is a complete sample script:
📋 Calling Up the Revision
"The next item of business is the consideration of the proposed revision to the bylaws, as prepared and presented by the Bylaws Revision Committee. The chair recognizes the committee chair to present the report."
[Committee presents report]
"The revision committee has presented a proposed revision to the bylaws. The assembly will now consider this revision section by section. Members may offer amendments to each section as it is called. The existing bylaws remain in force until and unless the assembly adopts the revision as a whole.
We will now proceed to consider the proposed revision section by section."
📋 Calling Each Section
"Section 1 is as follows: [reads or has read Section 1]. Are there any amendments to Section 1?"
[If an amendment is offered, process it normally. When finished:]
"Are there any further amendments to Section 1? [Pause.] Hearing none, we proceed to Section 2."
[Repeat for each section.]
📋 After All Sections Are Called
"All sections of the proposed revision have been considered. The proposed revision as a whole, including all amendments adopted, is now open for any further amendments to any section. Are there any further amendments?"
[Process any additional amendments. When none remain:]
"There are no further amendments. The question is on the adoption of the proposed revision to the bylaws as amended. Those in favor, say aye... Those opposed, say no... The ayes have it and the proposed revision is adopted. The revised bylaws are now in effect."