Previous notice requirement for a bylaw general revision when bylaws are silent
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What is the previous notice requirement for a general revision of the bylaws if the current bylaws are silent on the matter?
Previous Notice for a General Revision of Bylaws
When the current bylaws are silent on the notice requirement for a general revision (complete rewrite), Robert's Rules provides a default rule.
The Requirement
A general revision of the bylaws requires the same notice as an amendment to the bylaws — that is, whatever previous notice would be required for any bylaw amendment under the organization's bylaws.
However, if the bylaws are entirely silent on notice for amendments as well, Robert's Rules requires:
Previous notice must be given — but the specific notice standard defaults to whatever is defined in the bylaws or standing rules for previous notice generally. If truly nothing is specified, Robert's Rules states that notice of the proposed revision must be given at the previous meeting or in the call of the meeting at which it will be considered.
Key Principles
| Situation | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Bylaws specify amendment notice | Use that same notice for a revision |
| Bylaws silent on notice | Give notice at previous meeting or in the meeting call |
| No notice given at all | The revision cannot be adopted at that meeting |
Important Distinctions
- A general revision is treated as a single main motion, even though it replaces the entire document
- Previous notice is always required for bylaw amendments and revisions — this requirement cannot be waived, even by unanimous consent
- The notice should make clear that a complete revision is being proposed, not merely an amendment
Practical Advice
If your bylaws are silent, the safest practice is to:
- Announce the proposed revision at the previous regular meeting, AND
- Include notice in the call/notice of the meeting where it will be voted on
This ensures members have adequate opportunity to review the revision before being asked to vote.