Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Must proposed amendments identify the member who submitted them to a committee

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A committee is reviewing proposed amendments submitted by the parent body and developing recommendations to bring back to that body. Must the proposed amendments list the name of the member who proposed each one? And can the committee chair suppress that discussion by simply omitting it from the agenda?

Committee Review of Proposed Amendments

Attribution of Amendments

There is no requirement in Robert's Rules that proposed amendments list the names of the members who proposed them. Robert's Rules' rules governing committees and their work do not mandate attribution of proposals by member name.

However, whether names should be included may depend on:

  • Your organization's bylaws or special rules of order
  • Standing rules adopted by the body or committee
  • The specific charge given to the committee by the parent body

If the parent body specifically directed the committee to track and report who proposed what, that instruction would govern.


Can the Committee Chair Suppress Discussion by Controlling the Agenda?

This is the more significant procedural question — and the answer is generally no.

The Chair's Limited Authority

The committee chair cannot unilaterally suppress legitimate business by simply omitting it from the agenda. Under Robert's Rules:

  • The agenda is subject to adoption or amendment by the committee members themselves
  • Any member can move to amend the agenda to add an item before it is adopted
  • A member can raise the issue as new business or move to add it to the agenda

Under Robert's Rules, the presiding officer has no power to keep the body from taking up a matter it is entitled to consider. The members, by majority vote, control what the body takes up, and the chair's rulings are subject to appeal.

What Members Can Do

If the chair attempts to skip or block discussion:

  1. Move to Amend the Agenda — before adoption, any member may move to add the item; requires a majority vote
  2. Raise a Point of Order — if the chair rules improperly, a member may challenge that ruling
  3. Appeal from the Decision of the Chair — if the chair makes an unfavorable ruling, it can be appealed to the committee; requires a second, is debatable, and is decided by majority vote (a tie sustains the chair)

Key Takeaway

Question Answer
Must amendments list proposers' names? Not under Robert's Rules — check local rules
Can the chair block discussion via agenda? No — members control the agenda by majority vote
What is the remedy if the chair tries? Point of Order → Appeal
Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions