Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Must proposed amendments identify the member who submitted them to a committee

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A committee is reviewing proposed amendments made by the body and coming up with recommendations to present back to the body. Must the proposed amendments list the member of the body who submitted each amendment?

Attribution of Proposed Amendments in Committee Review

The short answer: No, Robert's Rules does not require that proposed amendments identify the member who submitted them.


What Robert's Rules Says

When a body refers a matter to a committee, the committee's role is to consider the substance of what was referred — the proposed amendments themselves — and report back with recommendations. Robert's Rules does not require that proposed amendments carry the name of their originating member when submitted to or reviewed by a committee.

**Robert's Rules (Commit/Refer to Committee) addresses what is sent to the committee: the motion or matter under consideration, not a roster of who proposed what.


Practical Considerations

Whether to include member attribution is generally a policy or customary practice question for your organization, not a parliamentary requirement. Consider:

  • Arguments for attribution: Transparency, accountability, allowing the committee to follow up with the proposer for clarification
  • Arguments against: Encourages evaluation of ideas on their merits rather than by source; reduces political pressure on committee members

Important Caveats
  1. Your bylaws or special rules may impose specific requirements — always check those first
  2. The body itself could adopt a motion requiring attribution as part of referring the matter
  3. Some organizations (legislative bodies, etc.) have their own standing rules that may differ

Bottom line: Robert's Rules is silent on requiring attribution — it is a matter of your organization's preference or rules.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions