Must a motion that fails for lack of a second be recorded in the minutes
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a motion is not seconded, does it need to be recorded in the minutes?
Motions That Fail for Lack of a Second
No, a motion that fails for lack of a second does not need to be recorded in the minutes.
Since the motion never comes before the assembly — it dies the moment no second is offered — there is nothing for the assembly to act on. Minutes record what the assembly did, and in this case, the assembly did nothing. The chair simply states that the motion is not before the assembly, and the meeting moves on.
Why This Makes Sense
The entire purpose of the second requirement is to filter out matters that only one person wants to discuss. If the motion never clears that threshold, it has no standing as business of the assembly, and there is no reason to preserve a record of it.
Practical Note
If the secretary has already begun writing down the motion before realizing no second was offered, that notation should simply be removed from the draft minutes. The final approved minutes should contain no reference to it.