Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Is a motion to deny a valid motion under Robert's Rules

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Is a "motion to deny" a recognized motion under Robert's Rules of Order?

A motion to deny is not a recognized motion under Robert's Rules of Order. It is redundant — if an assembly wants to reject a proposal, the proper course is simply to vote against (vote No on) the main motion itself.

Why It's Problematic

If a main motion is before the assembly (e.g., "I move that we approve the application"), a motion to deny the same thing creates a logical problem: the assembly cannot have two contradictory motions pending at the same time, and defeating one effectively decides the other.

What to Do Instead

Depending on the situation, the correct approach is one of the following:

  • Vote No on the main motion — The simplest solution. If the motion fails, the proposal is rejected.
  • Move to Postpone Indefinitely — This kills the main motion without a direct vote on its merits and can be useful when the assembly wants to avoid being on record for or against the substance.
  • Move to Refer to Committee — If the matter needs further study before a decision.
  • Simply allow debate and vote — The normal process will produce a result.

If No Motion Is Yet Pending

If someone wants to proactively go on record rejecting something (such as a request or application), the proper form would be a main motion stating the rejection directly, such as:

"I move that the assembly decline the application."

That is a proper, affirmative statement of action — which is how all main motions should be framed.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions