How to vote on multiple recess month options and amend standing rules
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our bylaws allow members to vote on up to three months per year during which the organization will not hold meetings and will go into recess. Our standing rules currently specify three particular months. A motion was made to survey members about which months they would prefer to take off. The results show that three different sets of three months are most popular. How do we put those three sets to a vote and then amend the standing rules accordingly?
Voting on Multiple Options and Amending Standing Rules
The Core Challenge
You have three competing sets of months to consider, which means you can't simply take a yes/no vote on a single motion — you need a fair procedure that allows members to choose among multiple options. Here is the proper way to handle this.
Step 1: Bring a Main Motion to Amend the Standing Rules
A member rises and makes a main motion:
"I move to amend the standing rules by striking [current 3 months] and inserting [one specific set of 3 months]."
This establishes the main motion as the vehicle for the change.
Step 2: Handle the Competing Options via Amendment
Since there are three competing sets, the proper mechanism is primary amendments. Once the main motion is on the floor:
- A member may move to amend the main motion by substituting a different set of months
- Another member may move to amend that
- Only one primary amendment can be pending at a time
However, with three distinct options, a more efficient and fair approach is:
Recommended Approach: Motion to Use a Preferential or Sequential Vote
Option A — Sequential Voting (Most Common Under Robert's Rules)
The chair can facilitate this by handling the amendments in sequence:
- Main motion is made with Option A (Set 1 of months)
- A member moves to amend by substituting Option B (Set 2)
- The assembly votes on the amendment first:
- If the amendment passes → Option B is now in the main motion → a member may then move to substitute Option C
- If the amendment fails → Option A remains → a member may then move to substitute Option C
- Eventually the assembly reaches a final version of the main motion
- The final vote is taken on the main motion as it stands
Option B — Fill in the Blank (Most Elegant for Multiple Choices)
This is specifically designed for situations like yours (Robert's Rules, Fill in the Blank):
- A member moves:
"I move to amend the standing rules by striking the current recess months and inserting ____."
- The blank is then filled by members proposing the three options:
- Option A: [Month set 1]
- Option B: [Month set 2]
- Option C: [Month set 3]
- The chair takes votes on each option in a logical order (often most to least months away, or by when proposed)
- The first option to receive a majority fills the blank
- Then the assembly votes on the main motion as filled in
⭐ Fill in the Blank is strongly recommended here — it was specifically designed for situations where multiple values or choices are being considered for the same slot.
Step 3: Amending the Standing Rules
Once the assembly has selected the preferred set of months through the vote above:
- Standing rules can be amended by a majority vote at any regular meeting with previous notice, OR
- By a two-thirds vote without previous notice
Check your own bylaws and standing rules — your organization may have specified a particular vote threshold for amending standing rules, which would take precedence.
Recommended Script for the Chair
"A motion is on the floor to amend the standing rules regarding recess months. Rather than a series of amendments, the chair suggests — with no objection — that we treat the specific months as a blank to be filled in. The options before the assembly are: Set 1 [months], Set 2 [months], and Set 3 [months]. We will vote on each in turn. The first to receive a majority will be inserted into the motion."
Summary Checklist
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Make a main motion to amend standing rules |
| 2 | Use Fill in the Blank procedure |
| 3 | Propose all three sets as options for the blank |
| 4 | Vote sequentially until one achieves a majority |
| 5 | Vote on the completed main motion |
| 6 | Record the amendment in the minutes and update standing rules |