How to strike improper remarks from debate under Robert's Rules
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What is the procedure for striking a comment from debate because of a personal attack?
Striking Remarks from the Record
When a member makes a personal attack or uses improper language during debate, Robert's Rules provides several procedures to address it.
Immediate Options During the Attack
1. The Chair Acts on Their Own Authority
The presiding officer should intervene immediately without waiting for a member to act. The chair can:
- Call the speaker to order
- Instruct the member to withdraw the offensive remarks
- Rule the remarks out of order
Under Robert's Rules, the presiding officer's duties include enforcing the rules on debate and on order and decorum in the meeting.
2. Point of Order (Any Member)
Any member may rise and say:
"Point of Order!"
The chair recognizes the member, who states the violation. The chair then rules on whether the remarks were improper. No second is required, and it is not debatable.
Striking the Words Formally
If the offensive words were spoken and not withdrawn, the assembly can formally strike them:
Procedure:
- A member raises a Point of Order citing the offensive language
- The chair rules the words "out of order"
- The chair directs that the words be stricken from the minutes/record
- If the chair fails to act, a member may Appeal the chair's ruling
Requesting Withdrawal
The chair may ask the offending member:
"The member will please withdraw the remark."
- If the member agrees → remarks are stricken by unanimous consent
- If the member refuses → the assembly may vote to strike the words (majority vote)
Key Rules About Debate
Debate must be:
- Confined to the merits of the pending question
- Never directed at a person — arguments must address the idea, not the individual
- Free of defamatory, obscene, or abusive language
Important Notes
- ⚠️ Words spoken in debate are not normally included in minutes anyway, so "striking" is most relevant if a verbatim transcript or recording is being kept
- If behavior is severe or repeated, the assembly may consider a motion to censure the member or remove speaking privileges
- The chair has authority to call a member to order mid-sentence without waiting for a motion
Bottom line: The fastest remedy is a Point of Order raised immediately, followed by the chair directing that the remarks be withdrawn or stricken. If the chair fails to act, any member can Appeal.