How to rescind a motion that violated the bylaws
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How do I rescind a passed motion because it did not follow the bylaws?
Rescinding a Motion That Violated Bylaws
This is an important distinction: if a motion violated the bylaws, the proper remedy is different from a standard rescission. Here's a breakdown:
If the Bylaw Violation Makes the Action Null and Void
If the motion conflicted with the bylaws, it was void from the moment it was adopted — it has no legal effect regardless of whether anyone challenges it. (Robert's Rules.26)
Steps to take:
- Raise a Point of Order stating that the previous action violated the bylaws and is therefore null and void
- The chair should rule the action null and void
- If the chair refuses, Appeal the decision to the assembly (requires a second, majority vote overrules the chair)
Key advantage: A Point of Order on a null-and-void action can be raised at any time, even in a future meeting, not just at the time of the violation. (Robert's Rules.6)
If the Violation Is a Procedural Defect (Not a Bylaw Conflict)
If it was merely a procedural error (not a direct conflict with the bylaws), the action may stand unless promptly challenged. In that case, use Rescind or Amend Something Previously Adopted:
| Circumstance | Vote Required |
|---|---|
| Previous notice given at prior meeting | Majority vote |
| No previous notice given | Two-thirds vote OR majority of entire membership |
Steps:
- Give notice at a prior meeting (recommended)
- Move to Rescind at the next meeting
- Debate is permitted
- Take the vote
Practical Recommendation
For a bylaw violation, the Point of Order route is usually faster and stronger because:
- It doesn't require a two-thirds vote
- The action is treated as if it never happened
- It can be raised at any time
Important Caveat
If your organization has an attorney or governing documents that supersede Robert's Rules, consult those as well — especially if the action has already been acted upon or third parties are involved.