Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


How to rescind a motion that violated the bylaws

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


How do I rescind a passed motion because it did not follow the bylaws?

Rescinding a Motion That Violated Bylaws

This is an important distinction: if a motion violated the bylaws, the proper remedy is different from a standard rescission. Here's a breakdown:


If the Bylaw Violation Makes the Action Null and Void

If the motion conflicted with the bylaws, it was void from the moment it was adopted — it has no legal effect regardless of whether anyone challenges it. (Robert's Rules.26)

Steps to take:

  1. Raise a Point of Order stating that the previous action violated the bylaws and is therefore null and void
  2. The chair should rule the action null and void
  3. If the chair refuses, Appeal the decision to the assembly (requires a second, majority vote overrules the chair)

Key advantage: A Point of Order on a null-and-void action can be raised at any time, even in a future meeting, not just at the time of the violation. (Robert's Rules.6)


If the Violation Is a Procedural Defect (Not a Bylaw Conflict)

If it was merely a procedural error (not a direct conflict with the bylaws), the action may stand unless promptly challenged. In that case, use Rescind or Amend Something Previously Adopted:

Circumstance Vote Required
Previous notice given at prior meeting Majority vote
No previous notice given Two-thirds vote OR majority of entire membership

Steps:

  1. Give notice at a prior meeting (recommended)
  2. Move to Rescind at the next meeting
  3. Debate is permitted
  4. Take the vote

Practical Recommendation

For a bylaw violation, the Point of Order route is usually faster and stronger because:

  • It doesn't require a two-thirds vote
  • The action is treated as if it never happened
  • It can be raised at any time

Important Caveat

If your organization has an attorney or governing documents that supersede Robert's Rules, consult those as well — especially if the action has already been acted upon or third parties are involved.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions