How to reflect a standalone executive session hire in meeting minutes
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a standalone executive session is held to hire a new president, how should the minutes reflect this at the next meeting?
Executive Session Minutes and Their Disclosure
The Core Principle
Executive session proceedings are confidential, but the fact that a meeting was held and actions taken must still be reflected in the minutes. Robert's Rules draws a careful distinction between what was discussed (confidential) and what was decided (may be reported).
Two Separate Sets of Minutes
When a standalone executive session is held, there are typically two distinct minute records:
1. Executive Session Minutes (Confidential)
- Kept separately and securely
- Available only to members who were entitled to be present
- Approved in executive session at a subsequent executive session
- Record the full proceedings, including the vote to hire the president
2. Regular (Open) Meeting Minutes
- Record only that an executive session was held
- Include the outcome of any action taken, if the body chose to make it public
What the Regular Minutes Should Show
The open meeting minutes would typically reflect something like:
"An executive session was held on [date] at [time]. Upon returning to open session, it was announced that a new president had been appointed/hired, effective [date], at a compensation of [amount — if publicly disclosed]."
Key elements to include:
- Date and time of the executive session
- That the session occurred (not why, unless already public)
- Any final action taken (the hire itself), as actions of the body are generally reportable
- The vote tally, if a roll-call vote was taken
Important Caveats
⚠️ Members are bound to secrecy regarding the content of executive session discussions. Violating this confidentiality is a serious breach of duty.
⚠️ State/Local Open Meetings Laws (sunshine laws) may impose additional requirements for public bodies — such as requiring disclosure of compensation or the vote count. Always check applicable law, as it supersedes Robert's Rules.
⚠️ The executive session minutes themselves must be approved separately, in a subsequent executive session, not in the open meeting.
Bottom Line
The open minutes acknowledge that the executive session occurred and record the action taken (the hire), while the confidential details of deliberation remain protected in the separate executive session minutes.