How to raise a disciplinary matter against a board member at a board meeting
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What is the proper way to raise a disciplinary matter involving a board member who is attending the board meeting?
Disciplinary Matters Involving a Board Member
This is a nuanced area of parliamentary procedure. Here is the proper approach under Robert's Rules:
Initial Considerations
First, check your bylaws and any special rules your organization has established, as these take precedence over Robert's Rules on disciplinary matters. Many organizations have specific disciplinary procedures spelled out.
If the Matter Arises During the Meeting
Step 1 — The Member Must Be Given the Opportunity to Withdraw
If the board is considering charges against a sitting member, that member has the right to be present during deliberations unless the board votes to go into executive session.
Step 2 — Executive Session
The board may vote to go into executive session (closed session) to discuss the matter privately.
Under Robert's Rules, the board goes into executive session by adopting a motion to that effect by a majority vote.
- Motion: "I move that we go into executive session to discuss [matter]"
- Requires a second
- Majority vote to adopt
- All non-members must leave
Step 3 — The Accused Member's Rights
The member retains their seat during executive session deliberations unless the assembly votes to censure or remove them. They have the right to:
- Hear the charges
- Speak in their own defense
- Remain present during discussion
Formal Disciplinary Process
For serious disciplinary action, Robert's Rules outlines a formal process:
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Charges are preferred in writing |
| 2 | Member is notified of charges |
| 3 | A trial or hearing is conducted |
| 4 | The assembly votes on the penalty |
Available Penalties
- Censure (formal reprimand — majority vote)
- Removal from office (may require a 2/3 vote or specific bylaw provision)
- Expulsion from membership (requires formal trial process per **Robert's Rules)
If Disruptive Behavior Is Occurring Right Now
If the member is being disorderly during the current meeting:
- The chair calls the member to order
- If behavior continues, the assembly may name the member (formally identify them for the record)
- The assembly may vote to require the member to leave the meeting
- This requires a majority vote
Key Cautions
⚠️ Due process is essential. Robert's Rules requires that members facing serious charges receive:
- Adequate notice
- An opportunity to hear charges
- A chance to present a defense
Failure to follow due process can expose the organization to legal liability.
⚠️ Consult legal counsel if removal from office, expulsion, or potential litigation is involved.
Recommended First Step
Before the meeting, the presiding officer or another appropriate officer should:
- Review the bylaws for any disciplinary provisions
- Consult with legal counsel if warranted
- Prepare written charges if formal action is intended
- Notify the member in advance if formal disciplinary proceedings are planned