How to phrase an amendment to a motion when debate changes part of a rule
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can you give guidance on how to phrase an amendment after debate on a motion to change a rule, when only a portion of the proposed rule is being changed?
Phrasing an Amendment After Debate
Properly phrasing an amendment is important for clarity in the record. Here's how to handle it:
The Basic Structure
When a member wants to amend a pending motion, the amendment should be phrased using one of three forms:
1. Strike Out (remove words)
*"I move to amend the motion by striking out the word(s) '_____.'"
2. Insert or Add (add new words)
"I move to amend the motion by inserting the word(s) '' after the word ''."
3. Strike Out and Insert (replace words — most common for rule changes)
"I move to amend the motion by striking out '' and inserting '' in its place."
For a Rule Change Specifically
If the main motion is something like:
"That the rule regarding [topic] be amended to read: [new language]"
And debate has led members to agree on modifying a portion of that proposed new language, the amendment would be:
"I move to amend the motion by striking out '[original proposed language]' and inserting '[revised language]' in its place."
Step-by-Step Process
- Member seeks recognition from the chair
- States the amendment precisely, quoting the exact words affected
- Amendment is seconded
- Chair states the question on the amendment:
"It is moved and seconded to amend the motion by striking out '' and inserting '.' Is there debate on the amendment?"
- Debate and vote on the amendment
- If adopted, the main motion is now in amended form
- Vote on the main motion as amended
Tips for Clean Phrasing
| Situation | Best Approach |
|---|---|
| Changing a number or date | Strike out and insert |
| Removing a clause entirely | Strike out |
| Adding a new requirement | Insert or add |
| Replacing an entire sentence | Strike out and insert |
| Rewording substantially | Consider substitution |
If the change is extensive, a member may move to substitute entirely new language for the whole motion, which is treated as an amendment.
Practical Example
Original motion: "That Section 4 be amended to require members to give 30 days notice."
After debate, members want "30 days" changed to "14 days":
"I move to amend the motion by striking out '30 days' and inserting '14 days.'"
Chair then states:
"It is moved and seconded to amend the motion by striking out '30 days' and inserting '14 days.' Is there debate on the amendment?"