How to oppose a motion to lay on the table under Robert's Rules
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What happens when a member objects to a motion to lay on the table?
Objection to "Lay on the Table"
Here's how this works under Robert's Rules:
The Motion Itself
Lay on the Table is a non-debatable motion. This means:
- It cannot be debated before the vote
- No amendments are allowed to it
- It requires only a majority vote to adopt
What "Objecting" Means in Practice
Since Lay on the Table is not debatable, a member cannot simply object and stop it the way they might stop unanimous consent. Here's what actually happens:
- A member moves to Lay on the Table
- It receives a second
- The chair immediately calls the vote (no debate allowed)
- A majority vote determines the outcome
If members oppose the motion, they simply vote NO. If the majority votes no, the motion fails and the assembly continues debating the main motion.
Key Points
| Factor | Rule |
|---|---|
| Debatable? | ❌ No |
| Amendable? | ❌ No |
| Vote required | Majority |
| How to oppose it | Vote NO |
Important Caution
Robert's Rules cautions that Lay on the Table should not be used to kill a motion. If the intent is to kill the motion, the proper motion is Postpone Indefinitely.
Bottom line: There is no formal "objection" mechanism — opposition is expressed through the vote itself.