How to nominate a different candidate after a reelection motion is pending
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How do you make a motion to elect a new chair when there is already a motion under discussion for the incumbent's reelection?
Moving to Elect a Different Candidate While a Reelection Motion is Pending
This is an excellent procedural question. The answer depends on how the election is being conducted.
The Core Issue
If a motion has been made to elect the current chair by acclamation (or unanimous consent), you have a pending main motion on the floor. You cannot simply make a competing main motion — but you have effective tools available.
Your Best Options
Option 1: Move to Amend the Pending Motion
(Recommended approach)
If the motion is phrased as "I move that [the incumbent] be elected chair," you can:
- Obtain the floor
- Move to Amend by substituting a different name:
"I move to amend the motion by striking '[incumbent's name]' and inserting '[other candidate's name]'."
- This requires a second, is debatable, and passes by a majority vote
**Robert's Rules — Amendment by substitution of a word or phrase is a proper primary amendment to a main motion.
Option 2: Move to Amend by Creating a Blank
You could move to amend the motion by striking the name and creating a blank, which then allows the assembly to fill the blank with any nominee before voting.
"I move to amend by striking the name, creating a blank for the office of chair."
This opens nominations to the full assembly. **Robert's Rules and ** cover filling blanks.
Option 3: Move to Refer to a Nominating Committee
If the assembly wants a broader process:
- Move to refer the matter to a nominating committee
- This is a subsidiary motion, takes precedence over the main motion, and requires a majority vote
Important Notes
- ⚠️ If voting has already begun, it generally cannot be interrupted
- ⚠️ Check your bylaws — they may prescribe a specific election method that controls over general parliamentary rules (Robert's Rules.2)
- ⚠️ If elections are conducted by ballot, the proper time to nominate alternatives is before the vote is taken, during the nominations phase
The Cleanest Scenario
The ideal moment to raise an alternative candidate is before any motion for reelection is made — during the nominations phase — simply by saying:
"I nominate [another member] for the office of chair."