How to limit debate by time or number of speakers under Robert's Rules
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If our body wants to limit debate — either by time or by number of speakers — what is the process?
Limiting or Extending Limits of Debate
Your assembly can modify the standard debate rules through the motion to Limit or Extend Limits of Debate.
Standard Debate Rules (What You're Changing)
Under Robert's Rules' default rules:
- Each member may speak twice on the same question per day
- Each speech is limited to 10 minutes
The Motion to Limit Debate
Requirements
| Requirement | Details |
|---|---|
| Needs a second | Yes |
| Debatable | No |
| Amendable | Yes |
| Vote required | Two-thirds (2/3) |
| Rank | Subsidiary motion (takes precedence over the main motion) |
How to Make the Motion
A member would say something like:
"I move that debate be limited to 2 minutes per speaker."
"I move that debate on this motion be limited to 15 minutes total."
"I move that each member be limited to one speech on this question."
Key Points
- The 2/3 vote requirement protects the minority's right to be heard — limiting debate is a significant action
- The motion can limit debate by:
- Time per speaker
- Number of speeches per member
- Total time allowed on the question
- Closing debate at a set time
- It applies only to the pending motion unless specified otherwise
- It can be applied to multiple pending motions if the assembly wishes
Extending Debate
The same motion works in reverse — if your rules already have stricter limits, a member can move to extend those limits, also requiring a 2/3 vote.
Important Reminder
Simply shouting "question!" from the floor does not limit or close debate. That requires a formal motion for Previous Question, a second, and a 2/3 vote.