Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


How to declare a previously approved motion invalid for violating bylaws

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


What is needed to declare a previously approved motion invalid if it is found that it violates the bylaws?

Declaring a Previously Approved Motion Invalid Due to Bylaw Violation

The Short Answer

If a motion that was adopted violates the organization's bylaws, it is considered null and void from the moment it was adopted — it has no legal force regardless of whether it has been formally declared invalid. However, proper procedure should still be followed to formally address it.


Key Principle: Automatic Nullity

Robert's Rules is clear that any action taken by an assembly that conflicts with the organization's bylaws is null and void. This is true even if the motion passed unanimously.

Robert's Rules (Point of Order) and — actions in violation of the governing documents have no validity.


Procedural Options

Option 1 — Point of Order (Preferred if discovered promptly)
  • Any member raises a Point of Order calling attention to the bylaw conflict
  • The chair rules on the point
  • If the chair agrees, the chair declares the action null and void
  • If the chair disagrees, the ruling can be Appealed (majority or tie vote sustains the chair)
  • Best used: When the violation is discovered soon after adoption
  • Note: For continuing violations, a Point of Order is in order at any time

Option 2 — Motion to Rescind (If the violation is debatable)
  • A member moves to Rescind the previously adopted motion
  • Requires:
    • Second
    • Debate allowed
    • 2/3 vote OR majority vote with previous notice OR majority of the entire membership
  • Caution: Rescinding is technically unnecessary if the motion is truly null and void, but it clarifies the record

Option 3 — Declaring the Action Null and Void by the Chair
  • If the bylaw violation is clear and unambiguous, the chair (or the assembly itself) can simply declare the prior action null and void
  • No vote required if the nullity is self-evident

Important Distinctions

Situation Point of Order Timely? Action Needed
Violates bylaws Any time Point of Order or declaration
Violates standing rules Only while still pending or at same session Point of Order
Simply a bad decision N/A Motion to Rescind

Practical Recommendation

  1. Raise a Point of Order citing the specific bylaw that was violated
  2. The chair declares the motion null and void
  3. Ensure the minutes reflect the corrected status of the action
  4. If needed, take proper action that does comply with the bylaws

Key Citation: Robert's Rules, and — A Point of Order related to a continuing breach of the bylaws may be raised at any time, and actions contrary to the bylaws are void regardless of the vote by which they were adopted.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions