How to challenge or declare a previous vote invalid due to irregularities
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How do you make a motion to declare a previous vote invalid because of irregularities?
Challenging the Validity of a Previous Vote
There are several procedural tools available depending on when you are raising the challenge and what kind of irregularity occurred.
Option 1: Point of Order (Immediate Challenge)
Use when: The irregularity is discovered during or immediately after the vote
Procedure:
- Rise and say: "Point of Order"
- The chair recognizes you
- State: "I raise a point of order that the vote just taken was invalid because [state the irregularity]"
- The chair rules on the point
- If you disagree with the chair's ruling, you may Appeal (requires a second, majority vote overrules the chair)
**Robert's Rules — A Point of Order must be raised promptly at the time of the irregularity, or it is generally considered waived.
Option 2: Point of Order for a Continuing Breach
Use when: The irregularity involves a continuing breach (e.g., the action taken was beyond the assembly's authority, violated the bylaws, or violated a fundamental principle)
Key distinction: Not all irregularities can be raised late — only those constituting a continuing breach may be raised at any time.
Examples of continuing breaches:
- Action taken without a quorum
- Vote required a two-thirds majority but only a simple majority was obtained
- Action violated the organization's bylaws
- Required notice was not given
Procedure:
- Rise and say: "Mr./Madam President, I rise to a point of order"
- State the specific violation and why it constitutes a continuing breach
- The chair rules, or the assembly votes on appeal
Under Robert's Rules, a point of order must normally be raised when the breach occurs. When the breach is a continuing one, such as an action that conflicts with the bylaws or violates a fundamental principle of parliamentary law, the point of order can be raised at any time while the breach continues.
Option 3: Motion to Rescind or Amend Something Previously Adopted
Use when: You want to undo the effect of the prior vote (even without an irregularity)
Procedure:
- Make the motion: "I move to rescind the motion adopted at [the previous meeting] regarding [subject]"
- Requires a second
- Is debatable
- Vote required:
- Two-thirds vote, OR
- Majority vote if previous notice was given, OR
- Majority of the entire membership
**Robert's Rules
Practical Recommendation
| Situation | Best Tool |
|---|---|
| Caught immediately | Point of Order |
| Bylaws or quorum violation (any time) | Point of Order (continuing breach) |
| Want to undo the action | Motion to Rescind |
| Chair rules incorrectly | Appeal |
Important: If the irregularity was merely procedural (e.g., someone spoke slightly out of turn) and not a continuing breach, and it was not raised promptly, it is likely waived and cannot be challenged later. Robert's Rules.