Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


How to challenge or declare a previous vote invalid due to irregularities

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


How do you make a motion to declare a previous vote invalid because of irregularities?

Challenging the Validity of a Previous Vote

There are several procedural tools available depending on when you are raising the challenge and what kind of irregularity occurred.


Option 1: Point of Order (Immediate Challenge)

Use when: The irregularity is discovered during or immediately after the vote

Procedure:

  1. Rise and say: "Point of Order"
  2. The chair recognizes you
  3. State: "I raise a point of order that the vote just taken was invalid because [state the irregularity]"
  4. The chair rules on the point
  5. If you disagree with the chair's ruling, you may Appeal (requires a second, majority vote overrules the chair)

**Robert's Rules — A Point of Order must be raised promptly at the time of the irregularity, or it is generally considered waived.


Option 2: Point of Order for a Continuing Breach

Use when: The irregularity involves a continuing breach (e.g., the action taken was beyond the assembly's authority, violated the bylaws, or violated a fundamental principle)

Key distinction: Not all irregularities can be raised late — only those constituting a continuing breach may be raised at any time.

Examples of continuing breaches:

  • Action taken without a quorum
  • Vote required a two-thirds majority but only a simple majority was obtained
  • Action violated the organization's bylaws
  • Required notice was not given

Procedure:

  1. Rise and say: "Mr./Madam President, I rise to a point of order"
  2. State the specific violation and why it constitutes a continuing breach
  3. The chair rules, or the assembly votes on appeal

Under Robert's Rules, a point of order must normally be raised when the breach occurs. When the breach is a continuing one, such as an action that conflicts with the bylaws or violates a fundamental principle of parliamentary law, the point of order can be raised at any time while the breach continues.


Option 3: Motion to Rescind or Amend Something Previously Adopted

Use when: You want to undo the effect of the prior vote (even without an irregularity)

Procedure:

  1. Make the motion: "I move to rescind the motion adopted at [the previous meeting] regarding [subject]"
  2. Requires a second
  3. Is debatable
  4. Vote required:
    • Two-thirds vote, OR
    • Majority vote if previous notice was given, OR
    • Majority of the entire membership

**Robert's Rules


Practical Recommendation

Situation Best Tool
Caught immediately Point of Order
Bylaws or quorum violation (any time) Point of Order (continuing breach)
Want to undo the action Motion to Rescind
Chair rules incorrectly Appeal

Important: If the irregularity was merely procedural (e.g., someone spoke slightly out of turn) and not a continuing breach, and it was not raised promptly, it is likely waived and cannot be challenged later. Robert's Rules.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions