Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


How to appeal a ruling of the chair under Robert's Rules

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If a member makes a point of order and the chair rules the point out of order, how can that ruling be appealed?

Appealing a Ruling of the Chair

The Appeal Motion

When a member disagrees with the chair's ruling on a Point of Order (or any ruling), they may Appeal from the Decision of the Chair. This is an incidental motion governed by **Robert's Rules.


Step-by-Step Procedure

  1. Immediately after the chair's ruling, the member says:

    "I appeal from the decision of the chair."

  2. Another member seconds the appeal (a second is required).

  3. The chair states the question:

    "The decision of the chair has been appealed. Shall the decision of the chair be sustained?"

  4. Debate may occur — the appeal is debatable in most circumstances. Notably:

    • The chair may speak first to explain their ruling (without leaving the chair)
    • Each member may speak only once on an appeal
    • The chair may speak again at the close of debate
  5. A vote is taken.


Voting on the Appeal

Vote Result Outcome
Majority voting YES Chair's ruling is sustained
Tie vote Chair's ruling is sustained (tie goes to the chair)
Majority voting NO Chair's ruling is overturned

The assembly's decision is final on the matter.


Important Notes

  • The appeal must be made immediately — before any other business intervenes
  • An appeal is NOT debatable if it relates to: indecorum, transgression of rules of speaking, or the priority of business — or if the Previous Question is pending
  • The chair's ruling on a purely parliamentary question is still subject to appeal

In Summary

A ruling of the chair is not absolute — the assembly always has the right to overrule the chair by a majority vote on appeal. This is a fundamental democratic safeguard in parliamentary procedure.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions