How to appeal a ruling of the chair under Robert's Rules
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a member makes a point of order and the chair rules the point out of order, how can that ruling be appealed?
Appealing a Ruling of the Chair
The Appeal Motion
When a member disagrees with the chair's ruling on a Point of Order (or any ruling), they may Appeal from the Decision of the Chair. This is an incidental motion governed by **Robert's Rules.
Step-by-Step Procedure
-
Immediately after the chair's ruling, the member says:
"I appeal from the decision of the chair."
-
Another member seconds the appeal (a second is required).
-
The chair states the question:
"The decision of the chair has been appealed. Shall the decision of the chair be sustained?"
-
Debate may occur — the appeal is debatable in most circumstances. Notably:
- The chair may speak first to explain their ruling (without leaving the chair)
- Each member may speak only once on an appeal
- The chair may speak again at the close of debate
-
A vote is taken.
Voting on the Appeal
| Vote Result | Outcome |
|---|---|
| Majority voting YES | Chair's ruling is sustained |
| Tie vote | Chair's ruling is sustained (tie goes to the chair) |
| Majority voting NO | Chair's ruling is overturned |
The assembly's decision is final on the matter.
Important Notes
- The appeal must be made immediately — before any other business intervenes
- An appeal is NOT debatable if it relates to: indecorum, transgression of rules of speaking, or the priority of business — or if the Previous Question is pending
- The chair's ruling on a purely parliamentary question is still subject to appeal
In Summary
A ruling of the chair is not absolute — the assembly always has the right to overrule the chair by a majority vote on appeal. This is a fundamental democratic safeguard in parliamentary procedure.